The 17 Best Eyebrow Pencils to Fake Fuller Brows in Minutes

This artist and editor-beloved brow pencil has a cult following for a reason. Associate beauty commerce editor Tiffany Dodson explains, "I've tested and reviewed a number of eyebrow pencils, and I keep coming back to this one from Anastasia Beverly Hills. Not only is it practically foolproof, but its formula and pigmentation is definitely one of the best."

This best-selling eyebrow pencil from L'Oréal retails for under $10, and has a super-fine tip that makes it easy to create thin, hair-like strokes.

This budget-friendly pencil features a long-wear formula and teeny tiny tip that makes it difficult to go overboard when filling in your brows.

Another of our favorite dual-ended products, this pencil from Selena Gomez's brand Rare Beauty provides soft, blendable lines that look natural when brushed through. It also nicely features a tinted brow gel that can be used alone or with its accompanying pencil.

One of the top-selling pencils at both Ulta and Sephora, this ultra-precise pencil from Benefit is best for faking natural-looking hairs. Use it on areas where you're sparse, then soften the lines with the attached spoolie. The best part? This tiny pencil is sturdy, so you don't have to worry about it breaking off.

Here's an Amazon's Choice recipient and editor-favorite pencil that's made in Japan, and contains a blend of moisturizing ingredients like vitamin E, squalane, and jojoba for a smooth application.

Created by makeup legend Bobbi Brown, this eyebrow pencil is completely waterproof, which means it's especially ideal to wear to the pool or the beach.

Dior customers agree: this retractable brow pencil is a must-buy for natural, yet polished runway-ready brows. The ultra-fine tip is sturdy, so it won't snap off the second you press it against your skin.

In addition to being smudge- and humidty-proof, this eyebrow pencil is vegan, waterproof, and refillable, which plays a small role in cutting back on beauty waste.

With a bevy of shade options for blondes, brunettes, and redheads, you're practically guaranteed to find a perfect match in this ultra-fine pencil from Fenty Beauty.

Another multitasker, this beloved 3-in-1 pencil includes an angled tip that creates both thin and thick lines, plus, hidden brow powder to further define and fill-in sparse areas. Use its built-in spoolie to brush through and soften your work.

Buzzy beauty brand Ami Colé knows a thing or two about creating cult-favorite products, and this pigmented, retractable eyebrow pencil—available exclusively in brown and black shades—is definitely one of them.

The angled pencil has the hold of a wax, precision of a pencil, and impact of a powder. Use the flat end to fill in larger areas in need and its pointy tip to create a few one-off strokes at the front of your brows.

Makeup legend Gucci Westman developed this popular angled brow pencil that contains a naturally-derived formula along with a fluffy spoolie brush for easy blending.

Here's a coveted pencil from It Cosmetics that comes in four universal shades suitable for a wide range of hair colors. Its formula is designed to not only mimic the look of natural eyebrow hair, but adjusts to its color based on the amount of pressure you use to fill them in with.

This is more than just a brow pencil—it's basically a transformer. On one end is a spoolie, and on the other is a brow marker that's ideal to sketch in a few flicks of "hair." And under the spoolie? A third product: an angled pencil, which is ideal for elongating shorter brows.

Sephora customers are raving about this nearly five-star-rated pencil from celebrity makeup artist Patrick Ta, which has a formula that not only lasts all day, but glides on like butter.